General Who collects Sports Cards

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up

madval

Active Member
Nov 20, 2016
109
151
I refuse to collect Downtowns. If I pull one from a pack so be it but I’m not buying or trading for any.
Card shop owner tried trading me a josh Allen downtown for my 3/3 Aaron Judge patch auto saying they were both worth about $750. I’m a huge Josh Allen fan but fuck that.
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
I refuse to collect Downtowns. If I pull one from a pack so be it but I’m not buying or trading for any.
Card shop owner tried trading me a josh Allen downtown for my 3/3 Aaron Judge patch auto saying they were both worth about $750. I’m a huge Josh Allen fan but fuck that.
2022 and earlier downtowns are great... but of course Panini ruined it this year by upping production and lowering effort on the art.

I think I saw somewhere that like 10 times more 2024 Downtowns have already been graded than 2023
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
Final count from my Mosaic international rip...

Paolo:
5 base
2 Red
1 Blue

Chet:
8 base
2 Red
1 Gold #9/10
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
Just did an order to submit 50 cards to Arena Club for grading...

Now comes the impossible part of narrowing down 50 to send
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
And.... finally narrowed it down to 50 (for now)

14 assorted Lamar rookies
8 assorted Josh Allen rookies
3 Mahomes rookies
3 Chet rookies (2 red, 1 #/10)
1 Paolo orange flash rookie
Mahomes Fathers Day 2019 (#/5)
Elly series 1 rainbow rookie
Justin Jefferson panini black silver rookie
Jalen Hurts panini black rookie
Acuna Fathers Day 2019 (#/199)
Saquon red/white/blue prizm rookie
Brandon Miller black and white monopoly man rookie
Bryce Young prizm draft Pregame rookie
Gibbs mosaic draft rookie auto
Gibbs mosaic draft #/10
JSN mosaic rookie auto #/10
4 Caitlin Clark numbered from the CC collection set
Christian Gonzalez prizm draft rookie auto #/15
Anthony Richardson Bowman U First Bowman auto #/199
Jasson Dominquez 1st Bowman Chrome Preview
Jasson Dominguez heavy lumber rookie
Aaron Judge update rookie
Jalen Brunson red/white/blue prizm rookie
 

Hauler

Been fallin so long it's like gravitys gone
Feb 3, 2016
49,520
61,581
Just did an order to submit 50 cards to Arena Club for grading...

Now comes the impossible part of narrowing down 50 to send
Do ypu get a discount on volume?

Is it worth having cards from the late 80s/early 90s rookies graded? Like McGuire, Canseco, Bonds, Larkin, Griffey, Bo Jackson, Jeter, etc
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
Do ypu get a discount on volume?

Is it worth having cards from the late 80s/early 90s rookies graded? Like McGuire, Canseco, Bonds, Larkin, Griffey, Bo Jackson, Jeter, etc
Nope... $14/card

And some of those would have value as a 10... but 9 or less and junk wax era isnt worth too much
 

madval

Active Member
Nov 20, 2016
109
151
Do ypu get a discount on volume?

Is it worth having cards from the late 80s/early 90s rookies graded? Like McGuire, Canseco, Bonds, Larkin, Griffey, Bo Jackson, Jeter, etc
Some of those rookies from the junk wax era can be worth grading and have value as a 10. Not easy to get 10’s though. Make sure It’s perfect before giving it a shot. Griffey is real tough
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
Some of those rookies from the junk wax era can be worth grading and have value as a 10. Not easy to get 10’s though. Make sure It’s perfect before giving it a shot. Griffey is real tough
Eventually I need to submit my Mark Jackson/Menendez cards... and the hoops Sam Vincent (with Jordan on it wearing #12)

Very unlikely to get 10s... but would be awesome if they did.
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
Well... finally sent off my 50 card submission.

A few weeks away to see how terrible it goes lol
 

madval

Active Member
Nov 20, 2016
109
151
I have a 16 card submission that should be back any day. Elly’s, Ohtani’s, Wemby’s, and my Judge auto.

Bought a box of Topps Midnight yesterday. Total bust. Khris Middleton auto and a 2/5 Haliburton/Walker was supposed to be the big hits. $275 a box.
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
I have a 16 card submission that should be back any day. Elly’s, Ohtani’s, Wemby’s, and my Judge auto.

Bought a box of Topps Midnight yesterday. Total bust. Khris Middleton auto and a 2/5 Haliburton/Walker was supposed to be the big hits. $275 a box.
I really like the design of that set... but absolutely hate unlicensed product.
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777

Also recently picked up a Chet rookie auto from Photogenic... another set I really like the look of... even though the football version was garbage as shit.
 

madval

Active Member
Nov 20, 2016
109
151

Also recently picked up a Chet rookie auto from Photogenic... another set I really like the look of... even though the football version was garbage as shit.
So what am I looking at here? Is that a website where you sell your own cards like COMC? Prices are high. I guess that’s for negotiation purposes. I have 2 Chet autos I’d take $200 each for if you want to resell them for double that on your site. 🤣
 

madval

Active Member
Nov 20, 2016
109
151
Accidentally posted the 2nd pic twice and cant figure out to delete it. Oh well
 

Chrit

RdotC
Aug 13, 2024
2,256
1,777
So what am I looking at here? Is that a website where you sell your own cards like COMC? Prices are high. I guess that’s for negotiation purposes. I have 2 Chet autos I’d take $200 each for if you want to resell them for double that on your site. 🤣
Kind of...

So Arena Club grades cards but also allows you to keep them there (as well as store any PSA/SGC/BGS slabs for free). That collection link just shows what I have there. They take 10% on sales so think of the true price as whatever is listed minus $14 (grading fee) and 10% (selling fee).

I have everything over priced as I'm not really looking to sell any of it at the moment unless someone wants to overpay. You can also propose trades on there.

Essentially its just a one stop shop for everything.